Ok so i have a good question i just thought of. I come across blogs that have posts with around 800+ comments that are dofollow and auto accept.
What i want to know is if i post a comment with my link and its the last comment, does google even notice?
Or does google only look at the first 100 or so comment links? whats the deal? I walk away from any blog with more than 25 or so comments. That is just me. From what I remember, Matt Cutts put out a video about this, and any PR available from that blog posts, gets diluted based on the number of comment. Made sense to me. And besdies, 1700 comments, looks more like spam to Google anyways. I thinks you post in another blogs? Google will index but it's too much for a day. Because google don't link spam. I will never be posting on such a page, even if it has a PR of 10. There is now use of it!!!. You can calculate yourself PR of 10 divided by 1700 and you will be getting a very small PR increase. Also you will be triggering spam alerts at Google. Quote: Originally Posted by paktangent
I will never be posting on such a page, even if it has a PR of 10. There is now use of it!!!. You can calculate yourself PR of 10 divided by 1700 and you will be getting a very small PR increase. Also you will be triggering spam alerts at Google. haha ok ok. But did you discovery how many backlinks per day is safe ?
There are two sides to this. Some say a link is a link. Some say you get penalized for "spam". If this was the case people would be posting their competitor sites to places like this - think about it. I'm more on the side of a link is a link. If anything it will not hp you but it won't hurt. Googles not dumb and thy are not going to start a spamming war between competitors. If I consider a site to hold value I won’t post links to it unless I think those links are at least on par with the site itself. Posts with 1700+ comments probably don’t fall into that. To me the quality of links matter. For that proper research strategy and implementation matters.
If you get quality links from 20 good sites your site can do miracles provided your site have relevant and useful information related to those keywords.
Now if we consider other way, like thousands of links creation - now for creating those links the time cost is another factor plus the relevancy of the back-links also reduces.
So as per my opinion, first analyze what to do and then make proper plan and research for that particular vertical and then implement those.
To me its smarter way of work than work hard.
What i want to know is if i post a comment with my link and its the last comment, does google even notice?
Or does google only look at the first 100 or so comment links? whats the deal? I walk away from any blog with more than 25 or so comments. That is just me. From what I remember, Matt Cutts put out a video about this, and any PR available from that blog posts, gets diluted based on the number of comment. Made sense to me. And besdies, 1700 comments, looks more like spam to Google anyways. I thinks you post in another blogs? Google will index but it's too much for a day. Because google don't link spam. I will never be posting on such a page, even if it has a PR of 10. There is now use of it!!!. You can calculate yourself PR of 10 divided by 1700 and you will be getting a very small PR increase. Also you will be triggering spam alerts at Google. Quote: Originally Posted by paktangent
I will never be posting on such a page, even if it has a PR of 10. There is now use of it!!!. You can calculate yourself PR of 10 divided by 1700 and you will be getting a very small PR increase. Also you will be triggering spam alerts at Google. haha ok ok. But did you discovery how many backlinks per day is safe ?
If you get quality links from 20 good sites your site can do miracles provided your site have relevant and useful information related to those keywords.
Now if we consider other way, like thousands of links creation - now for creating those links the time cost is another factor plus the relevancy of the back-links also reduces.
So as per my opinion, first analyze what to do and then make proper plan and research for that particular vertical and then implement those.
To me its smarter way of work than work hard.